Knee Pain? Why Clamshells and Glute Bridges Aren't the Fix (Part 1)

Why does everyone think that clamshells and glute bridges are going to solve their knee pain?
One of my running friends recently started having knee pain and she asked me what I thought about it.
She said she'd been to PT years ago for the same thing and they told her that her knee pain was from "quad dominance" so she always tried to focus on glutes in the gym
I asked her how many quad exercises she was doing in the gym... she said "none, because I need to do more glutes."
Aaaaand there it is.
Why "Quad Dominance" Doesn't Make Sense
Here's the thing no one wants to hear:
As a physical therapist, I have never met a runner with knee pain who spent "too much time" training their quads. (key word: training) never.
The whole "quad dominance" thing? it doesn't make sense to me.
You're not having knee pain because your quads are strong or because you've "trained" them too much.
You're not having knee pain simply because of glute weakness.
You're having knee pain because you're doing a lot of movements that stress your knee but you haven't prepared your knees/quads for all that stress.
Your Knee Has to Handle the Demands of Running
Everyone loves to blame their pain on some other joint or muscle group, but sometimes it really is that simple: Having knee pain is VERY commonly a sign that your knee cannot handle the demands of running.
Which means we cannot expect clamshells and glute bridges to fix it, especially if we never train our quads.
Yet every runner is taught to train their glutes but is never told to train their quads...
Your quads are the muscles absorbing and producing force around your knee with every. single. step. when you run.
AND running is basically a single-leg jumping exercise, so every time we land, our patellofemoral joints are handling roughly 5x our body weight. five times.
And somehow that translated to "do more clamshells????" no.
It really doesn't matter how many clamshells and glute med exercises you do if your quads still can't handle the demands of running.
Why Glute Exercises Seem to Work (At First)
if your knee hurts with running or in the gym, and your PT says "okay, stop doing those things and do these hip exercises instead"...
Your knee pain will probably get better in the short term.
But not because the glute work magically fixed your knee.
It's because you stopped doing the things that hurt. you gave your knees a little break. you stopped pouring too much water in your cup, so it stopped overflowing.
Which is great, and yes, that is often step 1.
But if you don't do anything else, you skip step 2 and 3, and you go right back to your knee-heavy activity, and the problem wasn't solved.
The cup overflows, because you didn't do the right things to build UP your knees. to prepare them for the stress you wanted to place on them.
Step 2: Train Your Quads
Step 2. You HAVE to add the knee work in.
If you have knee pain especially with running and jumping, I would bet you need to better train your quads. Seriously. Show me the quad isolation exercises you do in the gym. If there are none, that is the first problem.
So hopefully by now I've convinced you that if you're a runner or your sport/workout/activity involves jumping or placing stress on your knees, you need to prepare your knees for it.
And now you're probably like - "ok then how do I train my knees better?"
SO GLAD YOU ASKED!!! 😜
If You're Currently in Pain
I will first say - if you're currently dealing with pain, we WILL need to start at step 1 (see above) because it's not just about adding a bunch of exercises to an already pissed off knee. I'll go into depth about that in Part 2 of this series.
My Favorite Quad Exercises for Runners
But for now, if you're wanting to add in more quad-specific work, here's some of my favorite quad exercises:
single leg knee extensions (you seriously can't beat these)
quad-specific split squats like this rig version
hack squats or heels elevated wall squats
plyometrics like this (chest UP, knees FORWARD) - start here then progress to no band
My Rules
pick 1 – 2 to start, NOT all of them.
build gradually, not zero to 100
keep pain under a 2 – 3/10 during and the next day.
The Plot Twist: You Can't Strengthen Your Way Out of a Volume Problem
Here's the plot twist:
Even if you have super strong, beautiful quads, if you go zero to 100 and do way too much too soon,
You're putting yourself at risk for pain and injuries.
Because - this may be shocking to hear from a physical therapist - no amount of strengthening exercises will fix a volume problem.
Solving the volume problem is step 3 - I'll explain more in Part 2 of this series.
If your knee is hurting right now and you don't know where to start, that's what we're here for! book a free consult with our team here.
Do Not Let Pain Define Your Potential: Take the First Step with Made 2 Move
You have worked too hard to settle for temporary fixes or fear-based advice that keeps you sidelined from the training you love. You deserve a team that understands your goals and has the tools to help you reach them.
Made 2 Move Physical Therapy offers a performance-focused path forward — built on finding the root cause of your pain, keeping you moving through the process, and getting you back to full strength with confidence.
Ready to stop guessing and start moving forward? Schedule your free phone consultation with Made 2 Move today and take the first step back to the training, competition, and life you are made to move through. Learn more about our team on our About page, explore our full range of Physical Therapy Services, or visit our Blog for more expert insights. You can also visit our Home page to get started.


